Decision makers often desire the subjective predictions of experts. Any mechanism for eliciting and aggregating such assessments ideally should be: (1) incentive-compatible; (2) information-weighted (i.e., individual assessments should be weighted according to the a priori unknown amounts of private information held by agents); and (3) self-verifying (i.e., the mechanism should not require any ground truth observations). Although subsets of these properties are attainable by previous elicitation methods, our mechanism of collective revelation is the first to simultaneously achieve all three attributes. Moreover, we derive budget-balanced and online variants of the mechanism.